Fortunately, common sense was restored in Canada and the Emergency Measures Act was ended.
The situation started when the Federal government imposed a vaccine mandate on truckers crossing the Canada-US border. This was done with no scientific basis, and very, very late in the pandemic as it was already dying out. It was particularly egregious as the truckers have been working throughout the pandemic and were hailed as heroes.
As a reaction, the truckers organized a cross-country convoy that converged on our national capital, Ottawa.
Many unvaccinated and vaccinated truckers, and many millions of supporters, backed the truckers. They were demanding an end to all COVID mandates. Other related groups of truckers blocked various Canada-US crossings.
The protests were completely peaceful. At the start they were obnoxiously loud honking their horns in Ottawa, but they stopped that by court order. They worked with police to keep essential traffic pathways open for emergency vehicles. There was a party atmosphere in Ottawa with kids, bouncy castles, portable hot tubs, and an outdoor dance club set up under the Prime Minister's office window. The truckers shovelled snow, engaged in snow fights, and kept the national monuments clear.
This infuriated the Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, who refused to meet (or send anybody from the government to meet) with the truckers, called them racists, misogynists, holding "unacceptable views", and they were "not to be tolerated". The government and the mainstream media (all heavily subsidized by the government) broadcast propaganda 24x7 claiming the protests were all of those things and violent with no proof of any of it.
There was one fellow with a Nazi flag, and one fellow with a confederate flag, and they were both quickly chased away by the truckers. Not before Trudeau's official photographer was spotted taking photos of them, making one wonder if they were false flags.
The movement raised $10M on GoFundMe, who under pressure from the Canadian government, cancelled the campaign and told donors they needed to fill in a complex form to get their money back, and any unclaimed funds would go to charities of GoFundMe's choice. Under intense public pressure they changed their position and directly refunded the donors instead.
The fundraising moved to GiveSendGo and within a couple of days raised $5M. Canada tried to pressure them as well, but they resisted.
The border blockades were all ended peacefully. Federal riot police came in with a heavy hand to clear out and arrest protesters in Ottawa. Several were injured, including by being trampled by horses. Organizers were arrested and thrown in jail without bail for conspiracy to do mischief. The reason for denying bail is that the judge said they were likely to face very long prison sentences.
While this was already underway, Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act, the replacement of the war measures act, for the first time in history. Using the powers of this act he began freezing the bank accounts (with no due process) of people they suspected of being part of the protest or supporting it. Using these powers they retroactively declared the trucker protests illegal. When asked if small donors would have their bank accounts frozen, the Canadian Minister of Justice said "you should be worried" and refused to rule it out.
The way the political system works in Canada is that we have a democratically elected House of Commons. The party with the most seats chooses a Prime Minister. Trudeau is the head of the Liberal party, and they are in a minority government, however they have allied with the New Democratic Party (even more left wing) under Jagmeet Singh to make a majority. There is also a Senate that ratifies laws passed by the house. Senators are appointed for life by the government of the day.
The Emergencies Act can be declared by the government and immediately goes into effect. However, it must be ratified in both the house and the senate in short order. Trudeau rammed it through the house with NDP support against the strong objections of the opposition parties. Because many of his own people and the NDP were dubious, he declared the vote to be a "Confidence" vote, meaning that if it was defeated, it would trigger an election. Liberals and NDP are both very unpopular and low on funds and knew they would lose badly in an election, so went along with it.
Seven Provincial governments stated their strong opposition, and court challenges were launched on the basis that the Emergencies Act has clear criteria for invoking it that in no way was met.
Canada received a tremendous amount of unfavourable foreign press over its actions, and condemnations from civil rights groups and governments from around the world, although the bought-and-paid-for Canadian press was supportive. Trudeau became an international laughingstock.
The Senate then began debating it. While a majority of the senators were appointed by liberal governments, most by Trudeau himself, it was far from clear that the motion would pass. One of the better (albeit longer) opposition speeches, that sums everything up nicely, was delivered by Senator Donald Neil Plett.
Stung by the criticism, and fearful of losing in the Senate (which arguably would trigger an election), Trudeau declared the emergency magically over 7 days after it had begun, despite earlier saying it would be in place for 30 days.
Democracy saved in Canada, for now.
Upper houses exist for situations like this. The waves of political passion should only carry so far before they must be slowed or stopped and examined. I know our system here in the States is imperfect, but the US Senate when it functions even somewhat properly is one of the most ingenious anti-authoritarian and anti-mobrule creations in political history.
ReplyDeleteYes, great wisdom in that design.
DeleteI think everyone should be a little more concerned about Russia right now. People should be at home and terrified of what this could become.
ReplyDeleteOne thing at a time!
DeleteRussia is wrong to invade, but what other choice do they have? The western powers are total hypocrites. If they support Ukraine, why has Ukraine not joined NATO yet? Because while the western powers would love to deploy nuclear tipped missiles aimed at Russia in Ukraine, and curb their influence, they dont want to defend Ukraine or deploy troops there and fight Russia with whom they have billions of dollars worth of energy trade. Russia on the other hand is right in saying that while they dont have missiles on the US border, the US has missiles on the Russian border. So yes, it is an existential threat for them. So they have no other choice than to invade. Sad reality of things, but brought on by the west as usual.
DeleteI agree. Ridiculously provocative of the West to flirt with Ukrainian membership in NATO.
DeleteWhat do you know! A Canadian writing about Canada! There you go, Julie.
ReplyDeleteI was struck by the good manners of the trucker protestors. Here in the US, demonstrators tend to loot and destroy property and injure people...like the black lives manners demonstrators.
Imagine raising money with Go Fund Me. Wow, what a concept. The lack of manners displayed here by republicans and black activists make a sad commentary on our country.
I'm impressed by the good manners and civilized behavior displayed by the truckers. Sure, they caused a lot of trouble for the economy of both of our countries. But they did it with class and manners.
Well, they were pretty rowdy, but good natured. But what do you expect from truckers? I LOVE truckers! Not THAT much trouble for the economy. The Detroit Windsor bridge was only shut down for a week, long enough to get their attention, but not too long to damage the auto industry (and there were other ways to go).
DeleteSeemed pretty simple to me. Canada has rules. As a US citizen, I must abide by those rules to enter your country. I had a Nexis pass when I traveled to Canada often. Rules are in place to keep us all safe. That's why the border was closed or very limited for months on end. I can respect Canada's decisions to keep its citizens safe and the truthfully did a better job then the US. The real reason this pandemics gone on so long is because of the people, like your protesters and ours who have refused to help get this under control. The virus doesn't care who you voted for and screaming protesters don't no more then the medical community on how to stop this. Canada's government is looking out for the majority of its citizens and not just a small percentage of the population.
ReplyDeleteThe "rules" seemed capricious. It was perfectly OK for the truckers to cross without vaccines for almost 2 years, and to be hailed as heroes, then all of a sudden, BOOM, right at the end of the pandemic when it was least justified. It was just bloody-minded.
DeleteYou seem to be claiming that MANDATORY lockdowns, MANDATORY masks, and MANDATORY vaccines made a damned bit of difference. The data certainly does not justify it. When adjusted for age and obesity, none of these mandatory measures seemed to have made a significant difference (as opposed to voluntary and sensible compliance with same).
I watched from the States with horror as I saw your beautiful country devolve into a what appears to be total authoritarianism. Tyranny can not stand when the people who are armed and have the shinny compliance devices (badges) refuse to follow draconian laws. Unfortunately, your police chose to side with tyranny. I have learned much to my chagrin that Canada unlike the United States does not have Freedom of Speech enshrined in a document. Governments cannot grant rights; they can only take them away. Our creator endows each of us with certain rights. Your government elected to take your rights and flush them into the sewer of tyranny.
ReplyDeleteMost of the cops were not happy with what they were asked to do, but it was "legal" (brutal and asshole cops notwithstanding). Thanks goodness the senate came to the rescue and stopped the government from being able to do this legally.
DeleteDemocracy saved? Not really, no. Will the truckers get their money and licenses back? Will those imprisoned without due process be freed? Will businesses harassed and closed be compensated? Will doxed donors be protected? The emergency order may have ended, but with the banks and media continuing to do Trudeau’s dirty work, he doesn’t need it. A similar chilling effect has happened in the US with social media and tech companies controlling the message that most Americans are allowed to hear. COVID provided the cover that would-be despots needed to move the line several more feet toward totalitarianism. And the majority of citizens let them do it or even encouraged it. Now that the pandemic crisis is winding down, oh, look! There’s a war! You’ll be called on to make “patriotic” sacrifices which coincidentally requires government to take more control over you. - david
ReplyDeleteWell, it looks like they can now sue based on the fact that any actions outside the narrow window of the Emergencies Act are illegal, and big question if invoking the act itself was legal. They should have all their accounts unfrozen else banks are liable.
DeleteThese events have deeply damaged how Canada is viewed by Americans. We no longer consider it a free country. The police thuggery and lack of due process and judicial review is something we never thought we’d see on our northern border. You have our sincere prayers.
ReplyDeleteNo surprise to us Canadians. We have been slipping down this authoritarian rabbit hole ever since Turdeau got into office many years ago.
DeleteIf you lived in Ottawa, you might have a different view.
ReplyDeleteBut you are rich: so even if you lived in Ottawa, you would have moved to your summer home north of Toronto to avoid the disruption to your life.
So it's easy for you to have these strong opinions when you don't live where it's happening.
I have friends in Ottawa: they were sympathetic to the truckers at first, but the incessant and insanely loud truck horns turned them against the truckers.
https://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/trucker-protest-noise-may-lead-to-chronic-annoyance-and-distress
You misunderstand - I'm not condoning the honking. I thought that was bad and largely counterproductive for the protersters. But they stopped when a court order was issued.
DeleteI think there was no need for the government to invoke the Emregencies Act because of... honking. (honking that was terminated by court order before the act was invoked, btw).
Now, can we agree that the government overreached in invoking the unneeded Emergencies Act?
by the time that they stopped honking, they lost all good will from the people of Ottawa.
Deletethey could try to regain it, but it was gone.
it was completely unlivable with that noise. It's no joke: those horns are unbearably loud.
For that reason, I have no sympathy for them. The honking went on for a full week.
That's not the point of my article. I agree with you. However there was clearly no need for emergency powers when regular powers shut them down. You can't seem to agree with that for some reason.
Delete🎶 Man if I was Senator, it'd be a honkless state 🎶
DeleteGuess they weren't honking around!
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GkfxdYrkRYk
Very nice!
DeleteLol, worried about honking. Such a first world problem lmao. Come to my country, India. Honking is our life! Infact we are taught to honk in driving schools hahaha.
DeleteGood perspective. I seem to recall Turdeau being very critical of India's response to violent protesters not so long ago as well.
DeleteI was watching Russell Brand on youtube lately, and he brought up the same point. Trudeau was critical of India and now sends police to beat up and pepper spray protesters here in Canada, who were largely peaceful. smh
DeleteHi Julie
ReplyDeleteVery interesting piece you have here. I watched most of the Senate debate on this matter and as an old political back room guy I would have suggested the Senate would have defeated the Emergency Act matter before them.
As a matter of convention a no vote in the Senate would not have triggered an election . The Prime Minister and his/her cabinet must enjoy the confidence of the House of Commons.
https://www.ourcommons.ca/marleaumontpetit/DocumentViewer.aspx?Language=E&Sec=Ch02&Seq=3
What should be of greater concern now is the Ontario Judicary remanding protesters in custody for simple mischief charges. In Canada we give bail to alleged violent offenders, drunk drivers that cause deaths , etc etc. Yet suddenly people charged with counselling mischief are being held in jail.
What happens the next time the end poverty group shuts the bridges down in Vancouver or the Climate protesters block streets in Montreal?
I agree. Trudeau did not quite have the senate under his thumb.
DeleteThank you for clearing that up re the confidence.
And yes, the hypocrisy with which Trudeau deals with left wing versus right wing protests is absurd. On the other hand, when the conservatives come in there will be a precedent for brutally shutting down left wing protests. Of course, that won't happen, as conservatives tend to value the charter and due process.
As always, quite informative. Thanks for taking your time to do it.
ReplyDeleteBogey
Than you, Bogey
DeleteI still don't understand what the point of this protest was. It seems that a minority of truckers did not want to get vaccinated. From what I have read, they wanted the Canadian government to remove the mandatory vaccine requirement for border crossings so that they could continue to do their jobs without being vaccinated, is that correct?
ReplyDeleteMany Canadians don't approve of forcing an experimental therapy into the arms of their fellow citizens, especially when the vaxed catch it and transmit it, and unvaxed with natural immunity much less so. Ditto for masks (those mandated, N95s are not, are almost useless), and lockdowns that have never been public health policy before and has arguably shown to be ineffective. And no, just because you have a different opinion does not mean you ought to force people to kowtow to your views. That's what it's about.
DeleteIts simple. The government does not have a right to force someone to put drugs into their bodies that they dont want to. It also does not make scientific sense. Orgs like the CDC and Health Canada are lying by saying that vaccinations prevent infections and transmission, while the majority of hospitalizations are vaccinated people! Masking mandates are yet another unscientific recommendation. People use these cloth masks, place them everywhere, dont wash them even and think that is gonna prevent infections. You are better of not wearing those things!
DeleteI disagree a bit on vaccines. They do seem to lessen the severity. And I think the only reason you see so many vaccinated in hospital is because there are so many vaccinated. But I still think it's a personal choice, especially because it's not that protective of others, there are vaccine injuries, the vaccine wears off, there are unknown long-term issues, and the absolute risk reduction amongst the young and healthy is "cross the street" level of risk.
DeleteI was only talking about transmission and infections. The vaccine does not prevent that. It does lessen severity to an extent though when infection does occur. The authorities seem to push this narrative that if you get the vaccine you wont infect others, which is also the reason for vaccine mandates and proofs. But this isn't the case as we can clearly see.
DeleteIt >may< decrease transmission and infection, via the same mechanisms that lessen severity, but the data is not compelling and the mandates cut far too wide a swath, including those where the benefits, if any, would be utterly trivial.
DeleteThanks for this summary Julie. One interesting facet that you haven't noted however is the fact that while there had been plenty of previous anti-mandate protests in cities across Canada, those were blacked out of the mainstream media coverage, whereas this protest was heavily covered in the media. That raises some doubts in my mind as to whether this protest was in some sense not what it seemed. And now when ywe have the government seizing the bank accounts of people who helped fund the protest, it's starting more and more to look questionable with regard to its fundamental purpose -- ie was it to identify and target people who disagreed with govt policy.
ReplyDeleteVery true about the lack of coverage of previous protests. It was pretty clear that Turdeau was attempting to use this as a Jan6 type incident to justify a power grab. Quite possible he instigated it deliberately. The trucker vaccine mandates at this late date made zero sense from the start. But the truckers were so peaceful, and brought the kids and the bouncy castles and the hot tubs, that Turdeau was forced to back down. True evil in that sorry excuse for a "man" and his cuntish partner in crime Craptina Freeloader.
DeleteFreezing and seizing bank accounts comes right out of the Bolshevik playbook. It was one of the first things they did after storming the Winter Palace in 1917. Trudeau appears to be emulating them. Hopefully he can be tossed out at the next election (unless of course the elites arrange for a stolen election like they did here in the States in November 2020).
ReplyDeleteI wanted to make sure I understood all the facts before commenting.
ReplyDelete